Are electric cars really worth it? Let's get things straight

marzo 19, 2025

In recent years, electric cars have been presented as the definitive solution for a sustainable future. But today the question arises spontaneously: are electric cars really worth it or are we faced with an illusion? The debate is more heated than ever, between those who consider them the only viable option and those who see them as an economic and technological obstacle. What is the truth?

Are electric cars really worth it? The problem of conflicting information

One day we read that electric cars are the salvation of the planet, the next day we are told that the European industrial system is not ready for the transition. The news follows one another with contrasting tones, leaving consumers in a sea of uncertainty. Who is right? And above all, who has an interest in maintaining this confusion?

On the one hand, governments are pushing for electric cars with incentives and increasingly restrictive regulations for combustion-engine cars. On the other, European car manufacturers seem to be moving cautiously, while in China production is advancing at a rapid pace with increasingly economical models. In the meantime, energy companies are investing in charging infrastructure, but the question remains as to when this will actually be accessible to everyone.

In this uncertain scenario, the consumer is faced with a difficult choice. Is buying an electric car really worth it or is it too risky a gamble?

Are electric cars really worth it? Lack of complete data

It is said that numbers don't lie, but it is essential to ask what data is actually shown. Media attention focuses on zero exhaust emissions, neglecting the environmental impact of battery production, from lithium extraction to disposal. The cost of a "full tank" of energy seems convenient, but the increase in electricity rates could change the scenario in a few years. Autonomy is also a point of discussion: the most recent models guarantee hundreds of kilometers with a charge, but how long does it take to recover energy and what are the ideal conditions to obtain the declared performance?

Too many variables remain outside the main debate, making an objective assessment difficult. Without a transparent and complete analysis, the risk is that of making decisions based on partial or biased data.

Are electric cars really worth it? The comparison with traditional cars

The comparison between electric and thermal cars is often approached in an unbalanced way, with arguments that change depending on the narrative. When talking about sustainability, the advantages of reduced emissions are highlighted, but the environmental cost of the entire production chain is rarely explored. When the topic is autonomy, the progress of electric technology is extolled, without underlining the difficulties of recharging in certain situations. Management costs are also put on the table, with electric promising lower maintenance costs, but with an unknown on the value of the used car and the actual life of the batteries in the long term.

It seems that every argument is presented to strengthen a thesis, rather than to provide a truly objective picture. This makes it even more difficult for consumers to make informed choices, based on real data and not on marketing strategies or sector interests.

Market and politics: who really decides the future of the electric car?

In addition to the technical and economic aspects, the market plays a crucial role. Chinese electric cars are invading the market with competitive prices, while in Europe there is discussion of duties to protect the local industry. Is this a sign of protection or an admission of difficulty? Some European manufacturers are already slowing down investments in electric, aware that the transition could take longer than expected.

In the meantime, pollution levels in cities remain high, especially in the colder months, when pollutants accumulate. If the electric car were really the definitive solution, why do environmental data not show a significant improvement? Perhaps the problem of sustainable mobility is more complex and cannot be solved simply by replacing one type of vehicle with another.

BLOG CATEGORIES

Blog

MECHANICS IN PILLS

LAST NEWS FROM MECHANICS